When it comes to breast health, early detection is key. Both ultrasound and mammogram are widely used imaging tools that help identify abnormalities, such as lumps, cysts, or tumors.
See how they compare on this page: https://healthclinicgroup.com/ultrasound-vs-mammogram-which-is-better/. This article will break down the differences between ultrasound and mammogram.
It will compare how they work, when they're recommended, and their advantages and drawbacks. Can we begin?
What is a Mammogram?
A mammogram is a low-dose X-ray of the breast. It is used to detect breast cancer early, often before any physical symptoms appear.
Mammograms take two-dimensional images of the breast tissue to help doctors spot small calcifications, tumors, or other abnormalities. During a mammogram, your breast is compressed between two plates to spread out the tissue.
The X-ray machine then captures detailed images of the breast from multiple angles. The compression might feel uncomfortable but lasts only a few seconds. Mammograms are particularly effective for detecting:
-
Microcalcifications which are small calcium deposits that could indicate early cancer
-
Tumors that are too small to feel through a physical exam
Mammograms are typically recommended for:
-
Women aged 40 and above as part of routine breast cancer screening.
-
Women at higher risk of breast cancer (due to family history or genetic factors).
It’s important to note that mammograms are less effective for younger women or those with dense breast tissue. Dense tissue can make it harder to spot abnormalities, which is where other imaging tools, like ultrasound, may be useful.
So, what is an Ultrasound?
An ultrasound uses high-frequency sound waves to create images of the breast tissue. Unlike a mammogram, it doesn’t involve radiation.
Instead, sound waves bounce off tissues and are converted into images that can show the inside of the breast. For a breast ultrasound, a technician applies gel to the skin and moves a handheld device called a transducer over the breast.
The transducer sends sound waves into the breast tissue, and the echoes that bounce back create real-time images on a monitor. Ultrasound is particularly good at:
-
Differentiating between solid masses and fluid-filled cysts
-
Providing detailed images of breast tissue, even in women with dense breasts
Breast ultrasound is commonly recommended when:
-
A lump is detected during a physical exam, and more information is needed.
-
The results of a mammogram are inconclusive or require further investigation.
-
Younger women (under 40) with dense breasts need an additional screening tool.
Ultrasound is not typically used as a standalone screening tool for breast cancer. Ideally, it is often used in conjunction with mammograms for a more comprehensive evaluation.
Pros and Cons of Mammogram
Pros:
-
Effective for early cancer detection, especially in women over 40.
-
Can identify microcalcifications (small calcium deposits) that may be early signs of cancer.
-
Widely used and accepted as the gold standard for routine breast cancer screening.
-
Standardized procedure with clear guidelines, ensuring consistency in results.
-
Proven to reduce mortality rates by detecting cancers early.
-
Can detect tumors that are too small to feel during a physical exam.
Cons:
-
Discomfort from breast compression during the procedure.
-
May not be as effective for women with dense breast tissue.
-
Involves low-dose radiation, though the risks are minimal.
Pros and Cons of Ultrasound
Pros:
-
No radiation exposure, making it a safe option for repeated use.
-
Provides better imaging for women with dense breast tissue.
-
Useful for distinguishing between solid masses and cysts, offering detailed information.
-
Real-time imaging, allowing immediate interpretation and interaction.
-
Can be used as a guidance tool during biopsies.
-
Ideal for younger women who may not need mammograms but require evaluation of breast lumps.
Cons:
-
Not as effective for early cancer detection in some cases.
-
May lead to false positives, resulting in unnecessary biopsies.
-
Typically used as a supplementary tool rather than a primary screening method.
Key Differences Between Ultrasound and Mammogram
The choice between an ultrasound and a mammogram depends on several factors. Key determiners include your age, breast tissue density, and overall risk of breast cancer. Here are some key distinctions:
-
Technology: Mammograms use low-dose X-rays to capture detailed images of the breast, especially useful for detecting abnormalities like calcifications. Ultrasounds, on the other hand, use sound waves to create real-time images. They're particularly useful for differentiating between solid masses and cysts.
-
Best for: Mammograms are most effective in detecting early-stage breast cancer, especially in women over 40, where dense breast tissue is less of a concern. Ultrasounds are better suited for younger women or those with dense breasts, as they provide clearer images of tissues that X-rays might struggle to penetrate.
-
Radiation: Mammograms involve a small dose of radiation, which is generally safe but might be a concern for frequent screenings. Ultrasounds, however, are radiation-free, making them safer for younger women or pregnant patients.
-
Imaging Clarity: Mammograms excel in detecting calcifications, often missed by ultrasound. However, ultrasound is better at identifying fluid-filled cysts or guiding procedures like biopsies.
-
Purpose: Mammograms are typically used for routine screening. On the other hand, ultrasounds are more often used for diagnostic follow-up after a lump is found or a mammogram is unclear.
So, which is Right for You?
The best screening tool for you depends on your unique situation:
-
If you’re over 40 or at high risk of breast cancer, regular mammograms are recommended for early detection.
-
If you have dense breast tissue, an ultrasound may be used alongside your mammogram for clearer imaging.
-
If you’re younger or pregnant, ultrasound is a safe, radiation-free option for further examination of suspicious lumps.
Consult with your women's health specialist to determine which screening method is most appropriate for you. They may recommend one or both tests based on your personal and family health history.
It's a Wrap!
Both ultrasound and mammogram have their strengths when it comes to breast health. Mammograms remain the standard for early detection of breast cancer, especially for older women. Ultrasound, on the other hand, is valuable for those with dense breasts or when further examination is needed.
Be sure to talk to your doctor about your risk factors and screening options to ensure the best approach for your specific needs. If you're in Singapore, get in touch with a women's health specialist at;
The Health Advisory Clinic
One Raffles Place, #04-49
1 Raffles Place, Singapore 048616
(+65) 6226 6442
Our Style Guide
