5 Car Shops, 1 City: Finding The Tops in Indianapolis

You're not just buying a used car—you're signing up for road trips, late-night Taco Bell runs, and the occasional curb you swear came out of nowhere. So you deserve a car and a dealership that won't drive you crazy.

We scouted five standout car shops in Indianapolis that get it. From sleek showrooms to no-nonsense lots, here's your guide to used car buying in Indy, starting with the top-of-the-tops Indianapolis used car sellers. 

Indy Auto Man – Your First Stop

Indy Auto Man is among the top dealers in Indiana state, well-known for prioritizing customer satisfaction, introducing innovations for better service, and fast transactions with maximum transparency. No games, no bait-and-switch. Just a sleek inventory of pre-owned vehicles, real market pricing, and an indoor showroom where your shoes stay clean.

Quirky Perks:

• 7-day exchange policy – Car regret? Try again.
• Free Carfax + 150-point inspections – They do the homework for you.
• In-house financing – Even if your credit is somewhere between "oops" and "under construction."

Buyer Energy: Organized, skeptical, doesn't trust their ex or extended warranties—but Indy Auto Man earns their respect.

Gurley Leep Motorwerks – For Sleek Rides 

Vibe: Espresso-sipping, leather-seat-loving, "I just got promoted" energy.

Buy here if: You want a certified used car that looks like new but doesn't kill your budget.

Gurley Leep Motorwerks isn't your bargain-bin lot. This place caters to people who want luxury-light—think used BMWs, Audis, or Hondas that look like they rolled off a fashion shoot. The showroom is polished, the test drives are relaxed, and the staff knows the difference between "turbocharged" and just marketing fluff.

Why Buyers Love It:

• Premium used inventory (clean titles only)
• Financing options tailored to income, not just credit score
• Concierge-style test drives and upgrade options

Buyer Energy: Young professional. Just got a raise. Wants a nice car without owing the bank their firstborn.

Joe's Auto Sales – Your Cool Uncle's Lot

Vibe: If a food truck and a handshake deal had a baby.

Buy here if: You want something affordable, fast, and with a fuzzy steering wheel cover.

Joe's is where you go when you want a car, not a lecture. It's a family-run spot with bilingual staff, flexible financing, and cars that just need to get you to work without setting off the check engine light every morning.

Best For: First-time buyers, fresh starts, and practical people.

TruWorth Auto – Where Nerds Buy Cars

Vibe: Spreadsheet paradise.

Buy here if: You cross-check mileage, depreciation rate, and tire condition before ordering coffee.

If you're a data lover, TruWorth is your spiritual home. Transparent, online-heavy, and allergic to haggling, they list every detail down to tire tread depth before you ever show up.

Bonus: They deliver cars locally, so you could technically buy a car in your pajamas. We checked.

Oak Motors – Comeback Story Central

Vibe: Motivational speaker meets car dealer

Buy here if: Your credit report includes the word "oops".

Oak Motors isn't here to judge. They specialize in second (and third) chances with Buy Here Pay Here financing. You'll find basic, reliable cars and a genuine focus on helping people rebuild credit with monthly payments that make sense.

Hidden Gem: Their service departments are included in most deals, which makes life easier post-sale.

Which dealership is your energy?

• You want a chill experience, clean deals, and guarantees → Indy Auto Man
• You're fixing your credit and need support → Oak Motors
• You love luxury and won't settle for less → Gurley Leep Motorwerks
• You speak Spanish or want a quick & friendly deal → Joe's Auto Sales
• You price-check gum and appreciate Excel → TruWorth Auto
  

FAQ 

Q: Is it sketchy to buy a used car?

A: Only if you buy from a guy named Todd in a parking lot. Stick to well-known dealers with warranties and KBB free car history reports, like Indy Auto Man.

Q: What's a "Buy Here Pay Here" anyway?

A: It means the dealership acts as the lender. Places like Oak Motors offer this for buyers who can't get approved through banks.

Q: How do I know I'm getting a fair price?

A: Check several sources like Carfax, Kelly Blue Book, in advance, ask a car evaluation from several dealerships, and compare the prices before making a decision.